John Templeton Foundation Newsletter -- December 2004"Milestones" is a monthly newsletter of the John Templeton Foundation. In
interview format, it highlights the achievements of scientists involved in new
initiatives, research and programs in progress as well as awards and conferences
here and abroad.
***********************************************
The Templeton National Report on Acceleration
How Schools Hold Back America's Brightest Students
Authors' Commentary By:
Dr. Nicholas Colangelo
Dr. Susan G. Assouline
Dr. Miraca U. M. Gross
It's Tuesday morning, math class, fifth grade and the teacher is demonstrating a
complex word problem that requires percentages and multiple steps in division to
arrive at the answer. The material is new and not easy. Some of the students are
bewildered. Others are attentive, though tentative. However there is one student
in the class who hardly seems to be following at all - not because of
difficulty, but because of ease. Although she has the capacity to do algebra
with eighth-graders and test scores that indicate readiness to move on, her
chronological age says, "Not so fast."
That script is played out in classrooms across America - only the characters and
scenery change. Students well above the academic ability and readiness of their
grade-mates who want to be and should be accelerated to a higher level are kept
in place by attitudes and policies that are not based on the research.
Our two-volume report, "A Nation Deceived: How Schools Hold Back America's
Brightest Students," sponsored by the John Templeton Foundation is based on the
abundant research on acceleration covering the past 50 years. The essence of the
report is that America's schools routinely avoid academic acceleration, the
easiest and most effective way to help highly capable students. The research is
uniformly positive, and is in stark contrast to the negative attitudes, which
result in anti-acceleration practices. This report highlights the curious
dilemma wherein attitudes and personal perceptions trump evidence.
Acceleration is defined as an educational intervention that moves students
through an educational program at a faster than usual rate. It means matching
the level, complexity, and pace of the curriculum with the readiness of the
student. "A Nation Deceived" delineates 18 types of acceleration that are
organized into two broad categories: Subject-based and Grade-based.
Subject-based Acceleration demands cognitive ability--the work is faster paced
and more complex--but not necessarily social/emotional maturity. It allows
gifted learners to master material beyond their expected age or grade level
while remaining with their age and grade peers. Advanced Placement (AP) is
another example in which the student takes college-level courses while still in
high school and remains to graduate with his class.
Grade-based Acceleration requires both cognitive ability and emotional maturity
or readiness. By grade skipping, gifted learners progress more quickly from
kindergarten through 12th grade, leaving high school earlier than the typical
age/grade lock-step system permits. With each advance, the student must adjust
to a new, older peer group. In her research, Dr. Nancy Robinson of the
University of Washington concluded, "...for many gifted students, acceleration
options can provide a better personal match with peers than do non-accelerated
programs."
For most educators and some parents, Subject-based Acceleration is easier to
accept and implement. It seems safer and less dramatic. Multiple grade-skips and
very early entrance to college are considered radical. Educators worry more
about Grade-based Acceleration because it involves breaking routine and
traditions. In terms of the research, both categories of acceleration have been
found to be effective.
Our immediate and ambitious goal for the Templeton National Report on
Acceleration is, "To change the conversation about acceleration and gifted
students in America's schools."
That conversation began immediately after the September publication of "A Nation
Deceived," with articles in Time and Education Week as well as newspapers and
radio coverage across the country. The Time article "Saving the Smart Kids"
captured the complexity of the lives and needs of high ability students and
lauded the report for its persuasive evidence, concluding, "Perhaps 'A Nation
Deceived' will convince schools that the gifted sometimes need to run ahead
before they can walk at their own pace."
Clearly there is broad public interest in this research. When the Belin-Blank
Center at the University of Iowa set up a website on the report,
http://www.nationdeceived.org, there were 334,948 hits; 16,771 downloads; and
17,954 print copies ordered in the first eight weeks.
The report represents a national perspective. While it is primarily authored by
three people, "A Nation Deceived" represents the collective voice of some of the
most respected scholars in gifted education. A total of 17 scholars contributed
chapters to Volume II of the Templeton Report. These chapters were the
foundation for our synthesis of the research which constitutes Volume I.
Acceleration is one of the most researched topics in education and certainly in
gifted education. As Professor James Kulik of the University of Michigan
reported, "No other arrangement for gifted children works as well as
acceleration." Research results are uniform and compelling: acceleration of
gifted students works and works better than the alternatives; it is positive
both academically and socially for gifted students. All are rather powerful and
unambiguous statements. Further, findings indicate that acceleration is not only
the most effective intervention for gifted children but it is also virtually
cost-free.
The results of the research seem almost too good to be true. The fact is that
the research is very positive. The paradoxical reality is that in the face of
all the evidence, many schools either prohibit or discourage acceleration and a
number of educators hold views contradictory to the evidence.
While the myth says that students who skip will rarely fit into society, the
reality is that those very students tend to lead American society to greater
heights. Martin Luther King, Jr., leader of the civil rights movement graduated
from high school at 15. T.S. Eliot was accelerated. U.S. Supreme Court Justice
Sandra Day O'Connor graduated from high school at 16. And a young pediatrician
recently responded through the web site: "Last night, I said a thank-you prayer
for 'A Nation Deceived.' As a slightly accelerated student, I was
extraordinarily lucky to have parents and educators who were able to offer me
challenges... maybe not up to my potential, but enough to keep my mind from
stagnating and enough to keep my soul growing."
Acceleration is not just about one isolated, under-challenged child. It's about
many thousands of children and the future of America.
Looking forward, our ambitious goal is to coordinate a national effort to
promote awareness of the research and practice of acceleration and to establish
a center for further study and policy analysis, where none currently exists. We
are optimistic about the future for bright students in America's schools.
Web Links of interest:
Belin-Blank Center: http://www.education.uiowa.edu/belinblank
GERRIC: http://gerric.arts.unsw.edu.au/
Davidson Institute: http://www.ditd.org/public/
***********************************************
Dr. Nicholas Colangelo is Myron & Jacqueline Blank Professor of Gifted Education
and Director of the Belin-Blank Center in the College of Education at the
University of Iowa.
Dr. Susan G. Assouline is Associate Director of the Belin-Blank Center.
Dr. Miraca U.M. Gross is a faculty member of the University of New South Wales
and Director of the Gifted Education Resource and Education Center, GERRIC.
Editor's note: We are grateful to the authors for offering this unique,
first-hand commentary on their own research.
"Milestones" is a publication of the John Templeton Foundation.
To subscribe to any of the Foundation's various free publications, including
"Milestones," please go to http://www.templeton.org
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-NEWS is a service of the Metanxus Institute <http://www.metanexus.net>.
NEWS is a free opt-on only email distribution list which publicizes and
promotes events, publications, and opportunities related to the academic
dialogue between science and religion. NEWS text may be quoted or
republished with appropriate attribution to the source of the postings and
the Metanexus Institute. The views and events posted do not necessarily
reflect those of Metanexus or its sponsors. Metanexus reserves the right
not to publish unsolicited postings without comment. To subscribe to this
or other distribution lists, including our bi-weekly DIGEST edition, go tohttp://www.metanexus.net. Please send all inquires and submissions to<editor@metanexus.net>. Copyright 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004,
2005 by William Grassie.